feedback please..

i have uploaded 2 new revisions for you, thank you for the feedback.

1 star this time? What are you looking for that I'm not providing?

Over the last few days I asked you to read the Brief and to look at other different designs, but you keep re doing similar ones from the original design. I also asked for you to drop the "San Antonio 12 oz" part, not "Brewing Company." Plus I mentioned that I can't use the way you stylized "EliXiR" in the recent designs since it is almost exactly like another company's design that uses elixir, which is most likely trade marked.

Feel free to submit further designs but please read our comments, which you didn't seem to be doing. Think of totally different and new concepts.

I double checked, but the lowest rating I have given anyone is 2 stars. So I am not sure why you only a one star.

Please think of totally new designs.

Thank you all for the submissions. We are now rating them in order of our preferences so some star ratings have changed. Some will go up and some will go down. We are just sorting to keep track of the best submissions. Thanks. Keep up the good work.

The highest rating you've given is 2 stars so far? What can I do to get a better rating?

lol. Keith.he said lowest rating he gave. is 2 star. Relax.

Cheers
queenofnightsky

Everyone, I feel that I can not thank the designers enough. Everyone is creative and willing to work for just a chance at the prize and that is impressive. Some of you are submitting very good quality designs, they just do not capture who we are. I'll try to update the brief, in case there is something that could be stated better that will help draw out what we are looking for. RATINGS will go up before the end of the project so that it does not hurt your overall score. As I have mentioned before, do not pay too much attention to them now, we are just sorting the over 300 submissions we have received.

As far as imagery, when visiting places that serve alcohol, you often have to wait while choosing your beer or waiting for it to be poured from a tap. As a result, the first thing you often see is the artwork and designs on the beer coasters, taps, signs, etc. So the design must effectively speak for the beer before it is ever drank.